SDOX® Lake Oxygenation Case Study

The Clear Choice For Water Quality
BlueInGreen, LLC, was founded in 2004 by Scott Osborn and Marty Matlock and is headquartered in Fayetteville, Arkansas. It was formed with one goal in mind – to provide innovative new products for improving and maintaining water quality at lower cost and higher efficiency.

BlueInGreen’s Supersaturated Dissolved Oxygen (SDOX®) system was first invented in 1999 by Osborn and Matlock at Texas A&M University as part of a research program in Ecological Engineering. Now, over ten years later, our patented and portable gas dissolution technology is bringing the most affordable, effective water technology right to you.

BlueInGreen’s gas delivery technology is the most cost-efficient, flexible and effective solution for most ecological restoration uses. Impaired waters such as lakes, reservoirs, storm water detention and retention areas, dam tailraces and ground water can all benefit from our dissolved gas technologies. The SDOX® system is an ideal solution for delivering dissolved oxygen to rivers and streams to remediate impacts from point and non-point pollution, for providing refuge for critical species and for enhancing ecological services.

This case study is an account of BlueInGreen’s installation of SDOX® technology for lake oxygenation at Lake Atalanta in Rogers, Arkansas and at Lake Brittany in Bella Vista, Arkansas.

Background

BlueInGreen’s SDOX® system was demonstrated in two hypolimnion lake oxygenation applications as part of National Science Foundation funded projects.

The first hypolimnion oxygenation application was in Lake Atalanta located in Rogers, Arkansas. This lake has a surface area of approximately 10 acres with a depth of 28 feet. This lake was experiencing problems with anoxic water beneath the thermocline during summer and fall resulting in odor problems when the lake turned over in the late fall. This lake is located in a public park and is a popular location for fishing, walking and recreation. BlueInGreen received permission to test a small-scale system on the lake for a one-day test to determine if the hypolimnion could be oxygenated without disruption of the thermocline.

The second National Science Foundation lake oxygenation project was conducted on Lake Brittany located in Bella Vista, AR. This lake is much larger (approximately 35 acres) and deeper (75 feet) than Lake Atlanta.

Technology & Action

BlueInGreen’s SDOX® system is a patented/patents pending technology that operates in a method disparate to traditional dissolved oxygen (DO) delivery methods. Oxygen delivery efficiency for the SDOX® has been measured at 95% of oxygen used delivered as DO at the treatment site at a depth of 1 meter. Using BlueInGreen’s SDOX® method, the oxygen gas is pre-dissolved into a stream of water inside of a pressurized saturation tank to achieve dissolved oxygen concentrations of approximately 350 mg/L. The oxygenated water is then released from the saturation tank and mixed with the larger body of water being treated. The SDOX® requires no filters for incoming water and can pass solids of up to 3/8 inches diameter without clogging.

The SDOX® unit used for Lake Atalanta was very small-scale and was able to provide DO at a rate of 150 lb/day. The temperature and DO profile of the lake were measured using hand-held probes at several buoy locations at intervals of 2 feet. Profiles were measured two hours prior to operation of the SDOX®. The SDOX® was operated for two hours and injected approximately 12 pounds of DO into the hypolimnion. Visual evidence was collected from shore and from a boat indicating no destratification of the lake occurred. Another temperature and DO profile were collected immediately after oxygenation.

The SDOX® unit used on Lake Brittany had a capacity of 840 pounds DO/day, which is nearly 6 times larger than the unit used previously in Lake Atalanta. Lake Brittany was oxygenated from a dam (not flow through) at a depth of 45 feet.

Performance

First, let’s take a look at the results from the installation of the SDOX® system at Lake Atalanta in Rogers, AR.

Figure 1 shows the temperature profile of the lake before and after oxygenation. Clearly, the thermocline remains intact. An interesting lesson from this deployment was that the data also shows an increase in temperature in the zone where oxygen was injected. For this test, source water was taken from near the shore, not from the hypolimnion, so warmer water was injected into the cold hypolimnion. This problem was corrected in subsequent deployments.

Figure 1. Depth profile of temperature in Lake Atalanta, AR in oxygenation zone before and after SDOX® injection.

Figure 2 shows the DO profile within the hypolimnion both before and after injection. A small increase in DO can be seen at a depth of 14 to 26 feet. The DO rise is small, but the unit only operated for two hours and was very small in capacity.

Figure 2. Depth profile of DO in Lake Atalanta, AR in oxygenation zone before and after SDOX® injection.

Figure 3 shows a top-view of the oxygen injection to illustrate how broadly dissolved oxygen was distributed with this small SDOX® unit. All water had a DO of less than 0.5 mg/L at the depth of 20 feet shown in the figure. The single injection site was at 25 ft on the x-axis and 0 ft on the y-axis. Figure 3 indicates that oxygen was distributed at least 200 feet from the site of injection in a two hour time period.

Figure 3. Post-oxygenation top-view of DO distribution at a depth of 20 feet in the hypolimnion of Lake Atalanta, AR.

Now we will look at the results from the installation of the SDOX® system at Lake Brittany in Bella Vista, AR.

Figure 4 shows the location of the SDOX® unit and the buoy locations where temperature and DO were collected at depth intervals of 3 feet. Buoy 9 is approximately 750 feet from the injection site. The SDOX® was operated for 5 consecutive days and then turned off. Temperature and DO profiles were collected at each buoy location prior to injection and day injection began, 2 days into treatment, 5 days into treatment, 3 days after injection ended, 8 days after injection ended, and 16 days after injection ended.

Figure 4. Location of buoys where temperature and DO profiles were collected during oxygen injection into Lake Brittany, AR.

Figure 5 shows the temperature profile at buoy 6 in the center of the oxygen injection area. This data indicates that the thermocline was left intact during SDOX® injection. Visual evidence from a boat also indicated no destratification occurred and no bubbles rose to the surface of the lake.

Figure 5. Temperature profile at center buoy 6.

Figure 6 shows the DO profile at buoy 9, the farthest point from the injection site. The data indicates most of the hypolimnion reached a DO of at least 4 mg/L after 5 days of injection.

Figure 6. DO profile at buoy 9 the farthest location measured from SDOX® injection site.

Figure 7 shows the DO profile at buoy 6 near the center of the treatment area and this location indicates all of the hypolimnion was oxygenated to at least 4 mg/L.

Figure 7. DO profile at buoy 6 in the center of treatment area.

Figure 8 shows a top view of the DO concentration (by color) at three depths throughout the hypolimnion after 5 days of SDOX® injection. Data collected at the buoy marker sites is indicated within 700 ft y-axis from injection site and +/- 180 ft from x-axis origin. This data indicates that the DO plume created in the hypolimnion by the SDOX® injection extends far beyond the boundaries of the buoy locations. A finite difference approximation technique was used to estimate the total extent of high DO plume formation. Estimates indicate that after 5 days, the DO plume extends 900 ft from injection site. The plume continues to build until the SDOX® unit was shut-off (see figures 6 and 7) and the DO plume exceeding 3 mg/L extends to near the edge of the hypolimnion in figure 8. This test indicates that the smaller scale SDOX® unit should easily be able to oxygenate the hypolimnion of Lake Brittany after several more days of operation.

Figure 8. Top-view DO surface plot after 5 days injection using finite-difference extrapolation of buoy data over lake area at depths of 30, 36 and 42 feet after 5 days of treatment. Injection site was at x-axis of 0 and y-axis of 0.

Conclusions

BlueInGreen’s gas delivery technology is the most cost-efficient, flexible and effective solution for most ecological restoration uses. Critical data collected from both the Lake Atalanta project and the Lake Brittany project clearly illustrates the superior capabilities of BlueInGreen’s SDOX® technology.

The benefits of SDOX® are summarized as follows:

  • Cost effective DO delivery to warm or cold shallow water bodies
  • Automated control of the DO delivery rate for most efficient operation
  • Targeting of DO addition to a specific layer in the hypolimnion without mixing the temperature-stratified layers above
  • Addition of DO with minimal disturbance of sediments at the bottom of the lake
  • Targeting of optimum DO conditions for remediation, fish, and other aquatic species
  • Promotion of a shift to efficient and low-odor aerobic bacterial digestion of excess dissolved organics
  • Reduced dissolved metals via oxidation and precipitation